2016年3月23日星期三

Social Media Monitoring Project Part 2: Is BvS going to die this time ?


Since I am monitoring the marketing of an upcoming movie.I guess you are very curious about what's happened in the past two weeks.Did the DC comics and Warner Brothers keep their audience's passion and keep them talking about the movie?

Well, the answer is yes, but not in a way people will feel happy about it.


Ok,I guess you can see that something bad happened with the movie.We have a big C on the screen for a movie which was worked on for many years,there is no need for me to tell you how terrible it is.You may want to know how they end up with a C here, but I am afraid we need to save it for later.To understand the whole story, we will need to start from the beginning:


The successful keep of passion:

    

As we mentioned last time, passion is the main problem of their marketing and as we can see from the pictures above,they didn't make a significant improvement over the past two weeks.But at least they managed to keep their passion at a stable level and even increase it a little.This means even though there are very few topics for people to talk about during this time, they still managed to engage their audience in conversation.






I am glad to find they redesigned their Facebook page since last time.They add one area for people to get direct information about how to get their tickets and where they can find some resources related to the movie.This was a question asked by some of their audiences during the last time they tried to advertise their advance tickets,and now the problem is solved.Clearly we can see they are listening to their customers and giving immediate feedback.






Another great thing they did is to add their creations in social network platforms,like MSQRD,Snapchat and so on.These are newly developed apps which focus on share fun images.Those BVS implants are totally free on these apps,with one click,you can shoot superman's heat-emitting laser from your own eyes and share it with your friends! This is a very smart way to energizing your customers,and to engage them in marketing your products for you.And instead of creating their own app,they choose to participated into existing communities.Those apps already existed and their audiences use them, they just need to give people a new option and they will begin to spread your ideas.


Tried to embracing but not enough:



Then comes the first big event for the movie: The live stream of the BVS premiere.During the whole live stream,we can see DC and Warner were trying hard to embrace their customers.They chose three fans to join their live Skype meeting (You can see they are creator type from their background),allowed them to talk directly with actors and directors,ask questions about the movie.They use the hashtag "#BVS premiere" on social media networks,yo get as many people as possible to join the discussion of the night.

But as one of the audience members that night,I didn't feel I was involved in their conversation.Sure,they were talking directly to fans,but only those three in front of the screen.They ignore millions of people on the groundswell.The three people on skype were greet but they can't represent all of us.If I had a question,I could have posted it on my twitter using #BVS premiere,but no one in the live stream would have noticed it and asked that question for me.It's like a wall between people on social media and people in the event hall.If they could have picked at least some of the comments on social media and brought them into the event, then it would have been much easier for us to pass the cap.


Dawn of Crisis:






Although not perfect,their hard working to energize and embrace people still helped them reach a capstone after the night of the live stream.Now people have many new topics to discuss and those who already finished watching the movie have lots of things to share.What else can go wrong?



Then on the dawn of March 23rd,IGN gave their review about the movie with a "Just OK".Well,this is still not a big problem since IGN is only a media company and many people don't trust their reviews.But then the 36% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes really hit it hard.And remember the C+ at the beginning? That's a review given by one of their biggest fans on Youtube:


So if your loyal customers start to make negative comments about your products, doesn't it mean you need to do something ? So what did they do? Nothing, they gave no reply to their unexpectedly low scores at all.

At this time,most people haven't been able to see the movie yet,so those negative comments may not seem like a big problem,but slowly they begin to affect people's attitudes toward the movie.To make people feel bad even before they see the movie themselves.




Their passion actually significantly increased after the release of these negative comments, which means people are talking more about the movie.Even though it had more negative views,still people's passion are increasing.If they do something now,still they will able to save themselves,but they didn't.


At first,people on Facebook fought hard against those reviews.They left comments showing their confidence and passion toward the movie.To analyze why there are so many negative comments and to prove the movie is still worth seeing.But they got no feedback,and no support from the official account.It's like their customers are fighting for their products but they don't care about them at all. As a result, customer's passion is drained out and more people complain about the movie or simply stop talking about it.This morning I saw the first negative comment on their Facebook homepage and soon after that,many people began to leave similar comments about complaining or worrying about the movie.It is true that at this moment they are not able to change the content of their movie anymore and people's attitude toward a movie will difference from person to person.But people's sharing of idea will influence their feelings about your products and your brand is decided by what people say about you.This is why it's so important to manage your social media strategies even when the content can't be changed.


Why and how you should treat your negative review ?


In the case of marketing a movie, directly reply to negative comments doesn't mean admit failure.Instead,it means you are listening to what people are saying,and it also works as a way to energize those who still support your movie.And by talking to the groundswell in the right way,you can reach more people who are still interested in your movie.It will helps you build your brand for the long-term.

DC Comics has been working pretty hard to embrace and engage the groundswell.If we compare it with its main competitor,the Marvel Comics,we will find Marvel did very few things on social network when it was their time to market their superhero movies like captain American.

DC Comics already realizes the importance of social media for marketing their products,they just need to do better in support their own community.Even negative reviews can be turned into chances, if they are given supports.



2016年3月16日星期三

(Reading #3) How ubiquitous groundswell can be ?

So I guess this is the end of our writing experience and we all know that the groundswell has became ubiquitous, but how ? What's the crazies thing you can imagine about the expansion of groundswell ? So today I am going to show you part of our future, the potential of groundswell.We will start with this question: What do you need to become a writer ? Maybe it's a little hard to answer, so I am going to show you the answer directly below:


So, is it the true answer? Well, it used to be a true answer.In the old days,if you wanted to become a writer,you have to make a deep impression on a publishing company. After they believe your work is good enough to be published, you would be able to make your first step. Of course, there are thousands of people fighting for those very few chances to be chosen by big companies.So it's true that you need a few so called "talents" to become a writer.But today, if you want to become a writer, the only thing you need is a computer that can connect to internet and a willingness to write, that's all. 

Kawahara Reki began to publish his orginal novel online in 2002.He wasn't famous at that time and didn't have the skills to gain the attention of big publishing companies.No one can imagine this nobody will become a writer so famous among Japanese teenagers in less than 6 years. Years after he published his first work online, he attracts one of the biggest publishing companies in Japan to come to his house and ask permission to publish his work.With a pen and a computer, he changes the rule of how to become a successful writer.

Kawahara didn't have the resources to broadcast and advertise himself,but he did have the groundswell stand on his side.His work is born inside the groundswell,he published them in a virtual community and will always listen to what his readers are saying about his work as well as speaking to them about his own opinions.If his readers do not like this character,he will do something to fix it in the next chapter.Together, they are creating a better work.



Kawahara isn't the only successful example of a groundswell writer.Together with many other online writers, they created what is called "Light novel",a new form of fiction which is now popular among the whole world."Light" here means not to finish your job so quickly that your readers don't have time to make comments about what you are writing.They publish their works chapter by chapter, in a very slow process so that readers will have enough time to make comments about every detail of the story. Then you can makes use of these comments to write your next chapter.Doesn't this sound familiar with what we learned about engaging the groundswell ? I am not sure if they realized this phenomenon themselves, but as groundswell starts to change our way to communicate with each other, so does it changes the way we used to create media products.Not only novels, but also TV news, video games and movies.


Sometimes we may focus too much on the marketing and advertising function of groundswell, but if we look carefully enough, we will notice groundswell is ubiquitous around us. Similar to light novel, nowadays many TV dramas also start to release their products per chapter to allow more communication with consumers. Video game designers begin to offer beta tests for their users.The groundswell really doesn't have any boundary and that's why it's important for us to learn how to adapt.

2016年3月2日星期三

Batman VS Superman, Social Media Monitoring #1

Will DC Comics defeat Marvel Comics first time in the area of Movie industry?


DC Comics is one of the biggest comic company in the world,combine with Warner Bros,one of the biggest movie producer,there is no doubt that they will reach a huge success in the area of superhero movies.But the fact is,with their main competetor:Marvel Comics and Disney Fictures's successful movie strategy,DC and Warner Bros keep suffering painful failure in superhero movies.To turn the table once for all,they bring their newest product,the movie:Batman VS Superman,Dawn of Justice.

Fans of Comics ≠ Fans of Movies

DC Comics is famous in comic area and it has a huge number of fans.But that doesn't mean these fans will love your movie.And compar with the number of potential audiences,ther are still a small group.So when comes into movie,it is how to attrack those who never saw your comics before to see your movie becomes the most important issue.


The answer is again about your fans.Fans are loyalty and active consumers of your products.There are many creators and criticals among them,if you can get them involved into your marketing,clearly it will be easier for you to reach more audiences.So let's see how DC Comics and Warner did this time on marketing their upcoming movie.

BVS

Batman VS Superman,Dawn of Justice is an upcoming movie to be released in March 25th.Its Warner and DC's newest product in the area of superhero movies.Both the two main character is very familiar to audience,ignore weather you are a comic fan or not.And the idea to let them fight against each other is attractive enough to most of the people in the world.Right now is the finall count down to the release of the movie,let's see how well DC and Warner did this time in their marketing strategy.


Facebook and Twitter


Opening a new account specially for the movie is a good start.These two accounts are independence from DC comics's main accounts and specially prepared for the fans of their movie.This is a clear signal that they are working on reaching those who are not fans of comic books but still have intersting in superhero movies.Their facebook pages becomes a community for their loyalty fans to meet with recruits.There are never stop debate on their facebook page about who will win at last,batman or superman? For those who not familiar with these characters,they may vote for superman,but then those comic fans will jump out and begin to argue that Batman has the better chance to win.As they continue to argue with each other,these two groups of potential consumers begin to transform into one community.



The most effective way to introduce a comic character to new audience is through the words of their fans.Most of comic fans are creators on Facebook and twitter,they are eager to tell the story of their favorite character to others for totally free.So Why not let them to advertise the movie for you ? Batman VS Superman's Facebook account keeps a close connection with their creators,they will tell them the latest information about the news and let them to spread it out to even more people.Like when you tell a creator how to get his advance ticket,he will take a picture of his ticket and leave a comment:"It's happenning!We're less than a month away!" So everyone will knows the movie is coming and people can't wait to see it.


It's Happening!


However, when we look at twitter reach,things become more interesting,becuase none of the BVS's offical account is the biggest contributor to the topic "Superman VS Batman":

Does this means the company successfully get their consumers involved into marketing the movie for them ? Not exactly,but it's a signal of DC Comics are listening to the groundswell as well as trying to talk with the groundswell.


The top contributor for the topic "Batman VS Superman,Dawn of Justice" is CELEB MIX,a website focus on celebrity news.If you are a lover of movies,one thing you that you must concern is about celebrity,about movie stars.You may not concern about who is Batman,but you can ignore the actor of Batman,and that's how they can reach you.One thing DC Comics did really good this time on marketing their new movie is by using celebrity as their strategy to reach their consumers.They listened from consumers,realize they want to know more about Ben Affleck,so they gave them what they want.



Soon after the 88th Annual Academy Awards, they asked Ben Affleck appeared on Jimmy Kimmel Live to release a new clip of the upcoming DC film Batman vs Superman: Dawn Of Justice.And what's happened next is in the video.Another thing need to be mentioned here is that earlier this week,Warne announced there will release a rate-R director edition version of BVS in the future.At that time,every people on twitter want to know what they delet from the movie to make it to be rated as PG-13,then DC and Warn told them "Oh,we delect Jimmy Kimmel from the movie".

After that,suddenly people begin to make fun about the R-Rated Batman VS Superman,they start to imgae what may contins in the R-Rated version,make fun videos about it.Before they relesed this "Jimmy Kimmel in Batman VS Superman",some comments about the R-Rated is negative,some people thought it's a reach to their competitor Marvel's R-Rated superhero movie the Deadpool.But now,they turned it into something funny and use it to engage their consumers.That's a very smart way to talk with the groundswell.Well done,DC and Warner.

Trends Date:

The first week

The Second week

The Third week
Look from google trends, We can see their competors new movie the Deadpool forms a strong pressure on their pre-release marketing strategy but as time passing,the effect is going down and as it's time for the release of their advance ticket,it's now the chance for DC comics to take the topsite.As we can see in the last week,they begin to keep pushing something to their consumers,which cause serval climaxs of their trends.


The obviously increase after Feb 29th is a clear signal of the successful of their Jimmy Kimmel strategy.




But when we look at the social mention,we will notice although the strength and sentiment are always high,their passion is relatively low,which means people don't want to talk too much time about your brands.Although parts of the reason for this is because the movie isn't released yet,I think another reason for this is they didn't support their consumers enough.While people keep leaving comments on their facebook page,there is few replies from them.Their facebook only used as announcement,that get give their consumers the feel to be connected with you.That's will surely reduce tha passion of consumers.


Conclusion

From Batman vs Superman's pre-release markeing strategy,we can see DC Comics and Warner are working at on listening to their consumers and trying to talk with them.Their recently activity shows they are also working on engage their consumers,but they still didn't work hard enough on engaging and supporting their consumers.There are plenty of topics they can offer to their consumers in order to keep their passion about the movie,but they only focus on the one "Who will win",which may cause the loose of people's passion during the long pre-realsing period.And if they can leave more replies to people's comments,it will be more easier for people to get involved into marketing for them.
And since the movie will get released soon,DC and Warne will need a new set of strategy to connect with people,so I am curious to know what they will do next before and after the release of their movie.

2016年3月1日星期二

(Orginal #3) How should traditional media embrace the groundswell ?


Hello,folks! Today's post is not going to be a report on something new,but a discussion of a question that I have kept in mind for so long.There is no success story on this question for us to study,so I am eager to hear your thoughts and opinions about this question.The question is: is there any possibility for traditional media(newspaper,magazines,television ect) to connect with the groundswell of social media ?


You may ask, “does a newspaper need to connect with social media?” We all know social media represents people's new way of communicating with each other.Therefore,we may consider traditional media, like newspaper and TV, as "the way people used to communicate with each other." The conflict between old and new is quiet obvious. The relationship between them can be described as kill or be killed.Connecting them together is as crazy as putting predator and prey together in one cage.



However, if you look from another point of view, you will find traditional media is just another company described in our book Groundswell.They have their own problems with marketing,brand management and consumer support.Shouldn’t they tap into the groundswell ? If they are just another company, surely it won't be difficult for a newspaper to start its facebook account, right?


The problem is: media’s life is decided by how many advertisement it can gather.For a newspaper,the more people you can reach,the more advertisements you gather,and the more powerful you become.Media is only concerned about the number of people it can reach; we want to connect newspapers with social media because it can help them to reach more people.However,when a newspaper company opens a facebook account, it creates a paradox: if your facebook account can reach more people than your paper,then why do you need to keep that paper? You can just throw your paper into the paper shredder and start a media company based on social media.Google news is an example of this.In fact,in the recent action comic,Lois Lane used twitter to reveal superman's identity instead of the Daily Planet.So if Lois gave up already,why do we still try to keep traditional media alive ?


As part of our struggle (I use "our" because I have studied television news for years),Ithiel De SolaPool puts out the theory "Media Convergence"(If you didn't click the video above,please do it now.)It's a theory about how different kinds of media can absorb the advantages of each other.They think since every media form can be translated into digital media,it's possible for us to make products(information) using our tranditional way and then marketing them on social media.So that traditional media and new media can "convergence".However,I think they are trapped inside their traditional thoughts about communication.And that's probably why there isn't a successful case of "Media Convergence" till now.


Facing the challenge of survival, many media companies dip their feet into social media without too much consideration.I have visited NBC,CNN,FOX and BBC's facebook,their facebook account is juat another televsion used for them to advertise their products. There is nothing about them that engages,embraces,connects and supports the groundswell.They simply treat social media as a tool for them to gather viewing rate,but as mentioned above, that’s not connecting with the groundswell.




However, I didn't mean that "Media Convergence" is 100% wrong, I just think the way traditional media is using it now is incorrect.But I still can't figure out a way for traditional media companies to connect with the groundswell.For example, if NBC News wants to connect with the groundswell, they have to listen to what their customers really want to know and then focus on making news reports in those area.But this will totally change the way they used to making news programs and the advantages they carried from their old,traditional way of making news programs will totally disappear.And that's more like traditional media to be absorbed,turned by social media,instead of a convergence.

So, what do you think? Do you think there is one possible way to let traditional media get involved into the groundswell?